I like the version of pulp wars much more! So from me a YEAH to replace #24 - also i like DVAteds suggestion of the bloody version.

@DVAted - Sorry I missed your vote man :/


PULP WARS

To replace no. 24

Pulp Wars:

YAY - 4:

NAY - 3:

RESULTS - VOTE PASSES.

Ok, now we just need to decide which one to use

I'm voting for no. 1, @DVAted and @Cruz011 have already said this is their preferred version so I''l count them as votes. If you wish to change your vote then just re-vote here.

1 - 3:

2 - 0:

3 - 0:

4 - 0:

5 - 0:

Out of the 5 variations of the Pulp Wars banner I like the second the most so my vote goes to number 2.

Number 2 gets my vote, though I do prefer the original black and white version as it fits the main art she used. All the new ones posted still have that roughness that Drayce talked about though.

@DVAted - Has changed his vote.


PULP WARS

To replace no. 24

Pulp Wars:

YAY - 3:

NAY - 4:

RESULTS - VOTE FAILS.

Hey, GFX Specialists I want to nominate these 4 banners into the rotation

Spoiler:

Well, the first to banners that you want to bring in rotation are not from any game or i cant see any relation to a game. Perhaps something for a wallpaper.
The third banner "skyrim" is not bad but still needs a bit of work. I think its discussed before. The left and right side are simple black. Perhaps add some more pictures to fill the whole banner.
The last one is from metro i think. A very good one. But i wont replace it with #46. perhaps with #24 or #27.

Replace #20, #24, #27, #46 i vote with NAY

The first two look absolutely amazing and although I really like them I'm afraid they don't meet the requirement of being video game related so I have to vote NO on them.
The third banner has a lot of negative space that is not being used to it's full potential. Maybe after some tweaks it could be resubmitted and voted on again but for now I also vote NO.
The last banner is very nice, it's a good image showing the game and I like the creative use of text and therefore I vote YES to include it.

Sorry about the late response to this. @Xzisted has nominated 4 banners, as has been mentioned by other, the first two aren't really gaming related so I vote NAY. The 3rd banner, I like it but the black blank spaces on the left and right let it down quite a bit, so its a no on that as well. I vote yes for the 4th one, its fantastic and I prefer it to the Halo banner. Here's the scoreboard so far:


To replace Number 20

Spoiler:

YAY - 1:

NAY - 4:

To replace Number 27

Spoiler:

YAY - 1:

NAY - 4:

To replace Number 24

Spoiler:

YAY - 1:

NAY - 4:

To replace Number 46

Spoiler:

YAY - 3:

NAY - 2:

My vote for 20,27 and 24 are no, Id vote for the last one as well, but its mine so i guess i wont.

I nominate this banner from Mattafex to replace #27

I vote YES for @Mattafex's banner but I kind of like this one a bit more than the one @Cruz011 has nominated. I think the gradient in the text gives it that little extra flair.

Banner:

Incrible looks, is great I love the scene. My vote is YES for @Mattafex's banner(to replace #27). Great job !.

Drayce128 wrote:

I vote YES for @Mattafex's banner but I kind of like this one a bit more than the one @Cruz011 has nominated. I think the gradient in the text gives it that little extra flair.

Banner:

I like this too! I cant decide between those two so if the other specialist has the same suggestion i also agree with that one.

To replace Number 20

Spoiler:

YAY - 1:

NAY - 5:

RESULTS - VOTE FAILS

To replace Number 27

Spoiler:

YAY - 1:

NAY - 5:

RESULTS - VOTE FAILS

To replace Number 24

Spoiler:

YAY - 1:

NAY - 5:

RESULTS - VOTE FAILS

To replace Number 46

Spoiler:

YAY - 3:

NAY - 2:

ABSTAINED - 2:

RESULTS - VOTE PASSES


@Cruz011 has nominated a banner created by @Mattafex. I vote nay, I like the banner, its very good work but I agree with @DVAted, no. 27 should be replaced with another MGS themed banner.

To replace no. 27

Spoiler:

OR

Spoiler:

YAY - 3:

NAY - 1:

ABSTAINED - 1:

I should mention two different versions of this banner were nominated, if the vote passes we'll vote on which one to add.

Also, @Mattafex you can nominate & vote for your own banners if you feel it is better than the one you're proposing to replace. But you can also abstain if you don't want to do that its all good :p

Ha, i would vote but that would feel a bit big headed of me to vote on something i made. So ill pass