I know this has probably already been argued, but in Honest Hearts, Joshua mentions that he expected a different courier (Ulysses) to come after him, and from what we gain from the in-game lore, both are fairly strong leaders and can seemingly survive experiences that would likely kill any other normal person (much like the courier surviving a bullet to the brain), so to this I ask:
1)Firstly, which character spoke more to you and how do you think their philosophies and morals/actions stood out to you.
2)Secondly, who would win in a 1v1 between them if their paths ever did cross, and do you think the outcome would be different depending on the form of combat they engaged in (melee, guns, etc.)?

Personally, I think Joshua Grahams character development over the DLC (depending widely on the choices you made) had the most impact on me, I personally chose to fight with Joshua but taught him to show mercy in the final moments of the DLC which is said in the closing cinematic that learning mercy allowed Joshua to give not only others mercy, but give himself mercy for the things he has done.
Secondly, Given that Ulysses was a frumentari and was most likely better trained with melee weapons and also that Joshua Graham was a New Canaanite and was trained with the ins and outs of firearms, I believe that Ulysses would win in Melee and Joshua would win with firearms.

I look forward to seeing everyone else's thoughts on this!

1. Joshua was certainly more impactful on me.

His rise as a legate, fall and subsequent redemption were truly a great character arch worthy of the Badlands Legate.

2. No idea. Personally, I think it would go to Ulysses. He's a trained Frumentarii while Joshua is a 50sh year old burn victim. Not saying Joshua couldn't win but he's not really the great warrior he's touted to be. Yes, he's a badass mofo who's survived death many times but ultimately he's a skilled tactician and war chief. Ulysses is a warrior.

The question is... after the battle would Joshua truly be dead?

@Tribal Raven wrote:

1. Joshua was certainly more impactful on me.

His rise as a legate, fall and subsequent redemption were truly a great character arch worthy of the Badlands Legate.

2. No idea. Personally, I think it would go to Ulysses. He's a trained Frumentarii while Joshua is a 50sh year old burn victim. Not saying Joshua couldn't win but he's not really the great warrior he's touted to be. Yes, he's a badass mofo who's survived death many times but ultimately he's a skilled tactician and war chief. Ulysses is a warrior.

The question is... after the battle would Joshua truly be dead?

You make some very good points worth considering, thank you!
Also i'm pretty sure if Ulysses is able to defeat Graham, he wouldn't make the mistake of everyone else who has tried to off The Burned Man before him haha

I like to think Joshua because I love his story, but it would probably be Ulysses.

In game terms, it would definitely be Ulysses because his stats are crazy high compared to Joshua. In canon terms it depends. I wouldn't discount Graham because the man is one of the toughest people in the Fallout universe. Hell, before surviving being burned alive and thrown into the grand canyon, Hanlon says dozens of NCR rangers and snipers had tried to take Graham out, but he always came back. For a long time he was the back bone of Caesar's army, and an influential figure in his conquest of Arizona. That was all in his prime though, which is long past, whereas Ulysses appears to be slap bang in the middle of his.

Hard to say. Probably Ulysses in a straight up fight, but like I said, Graham isn't an easy guy to kill.

@IRORIEH wrote:

I like to think Joshua because I love his story, but it would probably be Ulysses.

In game terms, it would definitely be Ulysses because his stats are crazy high compared to Joshua. In canon terms it depends. I wouldn't discount Graham because the man is one of the toughest people in the Fallout universe. Hell, before surviving being burned alive and thrown into the grand canyon, Hanlon says dozens of NCR rangers and snipers had tried to take Graham out, but he always came back. For a long time he was the back bone of Caesar's army, and an influential figure in his conquest of Arizona. That was all in his prime though, which is long past, whereas Ulysses appears to be slap bang in the middle of his.

Hard to say. Probably Ulysses in a straight up fight, but like I said, Graham isn't an easy guy to kill.

Very good points about their ages and in-game stats! I never considered their ages, but now that I think about it, it would probably give Ulysses the upper-hand. And now that I think back about how hard that final fight with Ulysses was, Theres no doubt that Ulysses would win in-game haha. Thanks!

Graham definitely has the skills and experience, but there's a drive behind Ulysses that just seems far more intimidating.

Graham is reformed, he's trying to make right the mistakes he had before. He has a violent streak to be sure, a thirst for vengeance you can feed into, and he's tough as coffin nails, but overall he hears the call of a higher purpose and wants good to come of his actions. Not to mention, while he is capable, he is still physically destroyed, and likely nowhere near the able-bodied man he was before.

Ulysses is a man of will, young and full of hatred. Of all the characters in the game, he's the closest one to you. There's a kinship between the two couriers that square off. You two are like forces of nature so world shaking that everyone talks about the lead-up to your confrontation. He's cunning, experienced, and doesn't suffer any major, physical adversities. He has a keen knowledge of both old world and a modern technology, far in excess to a man like Graham. He also capitalizes entirely on his home court advantage, engaging in areas he's very familiar with, rather than charging into situations, guns blazing like Joshua does.

With all of this in mind, I really have to tip the advantage to Ulysses, as far as a battle between the two might go. It would be very interesting to see an event like this play out, with the two pitting their knowledge and skills against each other.

Depends on the battle we are talking about. Like is the battle something spontaneous? Is there time for both men to prepare? Is it a battle of wits or Brawn?
Before we get into that we should look at both men.

Graham is a man of strong faith in his beliefs, he will not be swayed in his decisions unless he is informed and convinced that they contradict these beliefs. Despite his kind and forgiving outward appearance and actions, he holds a deep hatred for all things legion and the man he once was. He has a huge following of tribal's who will lay down their lives for him and believe in his guidance. This also means that he is a charismatic man as well, at least to some degree considering that his speech check is so high and his followers are pretty damn loyal to him, also take into account he was the Legate and right hand man of Ceasar. Graham has fought in many battles, and recruited many men to his causes in his time. Besides his training, his resources, and his overall experience in battle, he also has proven to be a very durable opponent as well. Having survived a fall from the top of the grand canyon, while on fire, and being able to walk away from that. He lives with the pain of his wounds both physically and mentally every day of his life, yet still manages to follow his religious beliefs and spread the good word. The man is an unstoppable force or it would appear so. His major faults in this fight is his age, and hot headed approach to anything legion related. Being around the same age as Ceasar Graham is pushing 55, which means he is facing a disadvantage in this fight.

Now we have Ulysses a very obsessive former frumentarius whose extremely skilled in both technology and tribal remedies. Ulysses nature is one of curiosity and revenge. Much like Graham, Ulysses holds anger towards the one who wronged him, but also realizes that the two are closely linked with one another. Ulysses is very cunning and intelligent, but also very single minded in his goals. He is very hard to try and reason with, but once he makes a decision he will stick to it unless convinced otherwise. Being a former Frumentarius he is used to infiltration and blending in with his surroundings, making him very good at manipulation and stealth. Despite his intelligence he seems a little demented, now this could be due to the fact he has lost so many tribes in his life (One to the legion and One to the courier), but it still means that Ulysses mental state has to be brought into question. He also holds a very high code of honor, having been sent to kill Graham before hand but not following through. He even states that "Graham earned his life", when refering to the Burned man and why he didnt kill him. Ulysses shows great skill in combat as well, being able to hold off a large group of marked men (who are trained soldiers) along with the courier.

Now if the battle is spontaneous, Ulysses would probably be the victor due to his age, abilities and the fact that Graham didnt have time to prepare for the fight.
If the both men have time to prepare, I'd say it would go Graham as he would use all his resources against Ulysses including his followers.
If its a battle of Wits it comes to a standstill, as either men can decide to commit surprise attacks or manipulate those around them.
I dont think either would try to kill the other though since it just seems like they have a mutual respect for each other. Graham was willing to wait and meet who he thought was Ulysses(but in fact was the courier) in a civil conversation, and Ulysses has stated that he wouldnt kill Graham because he has earned his life by surviving the fall.